When I’m bored and being a chronically online, nosy little freak, I end up doomscrolling Reddit’s “Am I the A**hole?”—so obviously I had to drag that energy into Warhammer. I asked you lot to send me your “Warhammer AITA” stories and my inbox got absolutely flooded, so in this video I read through a bunch of the weirdest, funniest, and most divisive hobby conflicts and we decide who’s actually being “that guy.” We hit everything from someone getting called out for last-minute game flaking (and how social anxiety changes that conversation), to a store owner seemingly moving the goalposts in painting comps, to the most cursed tournament proxy situation imaginable (yes, including a plush Yoda “Wraithknight”). I also dig into sportsmanship—like the school league story where the rules changed and the reaction got a bit… holy—and the classic problem of experienced players stomping brand-new combat patrol kids with netlists. The big takeaway: most of this stuff gets fixed by having an adult conversation early, tailoring expectations to the setting (casual night vs tournament), and remembering that nobody is entitled to your online space if they’re bringing weird vibes. Also: if you’re calling the shop mid-dice roll to argue rules… please stop.