In this video I compare the HiBy R5 Gen 2 vs the HiBy R4, and it’s basically an old-school audiophile sound battle versus modern everyday usability. I break it down the way I actually use these players: sound first, then power, then the stuff that makes you either enjoy using it daily or get annoyed fast. If you care about that warmer, richer, more analog-style sound, the R5 Gen 2 still hits hard because of its Class A amp—especially for vocals and long listening sessions. The R4 sounds good too, but it’s cleaner and more neutral, without that same lush character. Power is another win for the R5 Gen 2, especially in balanced mode where it can push more current and handle harder-to-drive headphones better. But then the tables flip hard on usability: the R4 is way more modern with a newer Android system, smoother performance, faster app loading, and better overall day-to-day experience. Battery life on the R5 Gen 2 can be insane in economy mode (I’m talking over 30 hours), but Class A drains faster—so you’re trading battery for sound quality. My takeaway is simple: the R5 Gen 2 is for people chasing that specific warm Class A sound, but for most people the R4 is the better overall pick because it balances performance, usability, and price.