44 Nyx Buttermelt Stix Highlighter

The NYX Buttermelt Stix highlighter gave the prettiest glow and blended out so nicely with just my fingers. The effect reminded me a lot of my favourite Merit Day Glow (just a bit more golden), but for a fraction of the price. If you like a glossy, skin-like highlight, this is a winner.

Pros

+Gives a beautiful, skin-like glow
+Easy to apply and blend with fingers
+Similar vibe to higher-end stick highlighters

Cons

-Smaller than expected
-Golden tone may not suit everyone’s undertone

Featured in this video

NEW Drugstore Makeup for January 2026 - Sheglam NYX, Maybelline + First Impressions | Clare Walch

1K views · 2026-01-28 20:00:49

44 Nyx Buttermelt Stix Highlighter

Available on Go

Buy on Go

External purchase

Highlights

+Gives a beautiful, skin-like glow
+Easy to apply and blend with fingers
+Similar vibe to higher-end stick highlighters

Recommended by

Clare Walch